Submitting to Literary Magazines: A Practical Submission Guide

The literary magazine submission process has enough moving parts to humble even experienced writers — simultaneous submissions, response windows stretching past six months, and journals that receive upward of 10,000 manuscripts per year for a handful of open spots. This page covers the mechanics of submitting creative writing to literary magazines and journals: how the system works, why it behaves the way it does, where writers most commonly go wrong, and what a well-prepared submission actually looks like.

Definition and scope

A literary magazine submission is a formal offer of a manuscript — fiction, poetry, creative nonfiction, or hybrid work — for consideration by a periodical publication that selects content through editorial review rather than payment-to-publish. The distinction matters: literary journals are gatekept, not open-access vanity platforms.

The landscape spans roughly 500 to 3,000 active English-language journals at any given point, depending on how one counts online-only, print, and hybrid publications. The Poets & Writers database and Duotrope each index over 1,000 markets. These range from The New Yorker (acceptance rate estimated at under 1%) to regional quarterlies with acceptance rates closer to 3–5%, to newer online journals that publish emerging writers at slightly higher rates of 5–10%. Payment models run from nothing (contributor copies only), to token amounts, to professional rates of $0.25 per word or higher at top-tier venues like One Story or Tin House.

The scope of a submission typically includes a cover letter, the manuscript formatted to the journal's specifications, and sometimes a short biography. What it does not include — and this is non-negotiable — is any editorial negotiation before acceptance.

Core mechanics or structure

Most journals operate on one of two platforms: Submittable (used by the majority of mid-to-large journals) or a direct email submission. A smaller subset use Duotrope's built-in submission manager or proprietary portals.

The submission workflow follows a predictable arc:

Response times vary dramatically. AGNI and Ploughshares routinely take 3–6 months. Faster journals like Rejection Letters or SmokeLong Quarterly often respond within 30–60 days. Submittable's 2022 internal data indicated that the median response time across tracked journals was approximately 60 days, though outliers extend well beyond that.

Reading fees have become more common since roughly 2015. The Missouri Review charges $3 through its MORS system; Glimmer Train (before closing) charged $15–20. Many journals waive fees during specific free-submission windows or for subscribers. Fee-free submission options always exist; no writer is obligated to pay to submit.

Causal relationships or drivers

The structural pressures shaping how journals behave are worth understanding, because they explain behaviors that otherwise seem arbitrary or capricious.

Journals receive far more submissions than they can publish — this is not incidental but structural. A journal with 4 published issues per year and 8 pieces per issue publishes 32 pieces annually. If it receives 5,000 submissions, the math alone produces a 0.64% acceptance rate before a single editorial preference enters the equation. The literary magazines and journals landscape compounds this because digital submission has eliminated the friction of postage and paper, dramatically increasing submission volume over the past 15 years.

Editorial staffing is the second driver. Most literary journals run on volunteer labor — MFA students, faculty, passionate readers with day jobs. A journal with 3 paid staff and 12 volunteers reading 400 submissions per month cannot offer personalized feedback. The brief, standardized rejection is not coldness; it is triage.

The third driver is the economics of small-press publishing. Very few literary journals are financially self-sustaining. Many rely on university affiliations, grant funding from the National Endowment for the Arts, or subscription revenue. When a journal charges a reading fee, it is typically covering platform costs and editorial stipends, not generating profit.

Classification boundaries

Not all submissions go to the same category of publication, and the distinctions carry real practical consequences.

By prestige tier: Top-tier journals (Paris Review, Tin House, Kenyon Review, AGNI, Ploughshares) carry significant weight in book publishing, MFA admissions, and grant applications. Mid-tier journals with strong reputations in specific genres — Nightmare Magazine for horror, Strange Horizons for speculative fiction — carry equivalent genre-specific credibility. Emerging or newer journals offer higher acceptance rates but less professional resume weight.

By genre specificity: General literary journals accept fiction, poetry, and nonfiction. Genre-specific journals restrict to flash fiction, poetry, genre fiction, or creative nonfiction exclusively. Submitting a 4,000-word short story to a poetry journal is not a misfire that gets reconsidered — it is disqualified before a human reads it.

By reading period: Some journals read year-round (continuous). Others have defined windows: September–May (academic calendar), January–March, or contest-only periods. Submitting outside an open window means the work sits unread until the period opens or is automatically returned.

By rights acquired: First North American Serial Rights (FNASR) is standard — the journal gets the first publication right in North America; all others revert to the author after publication. Journals that ask for all rights or perpetual exclusive rights warrant careful scrutiny.

Tradeoffs and tensions

The simultaneous submission question sits at the center of the field's most persistent tension. Simultaneous submission means sending the same manuscript to multiple journals at once; exclusive submission means holding the piece for one journal at a time. Given that response times can stretch to 6 months or longer, exclusive submission effectively means a writer might submit a single story to 2 journals per year. Simultaneous submission is now accepted practice at most journals — Ploughshares, One Story, and The Sun explicitly permit it. A handful of journals, notably Narrative Magazine, still prohibit simultaneous submissions. Writers must read each journal's guidelines carefully and, if simultaneously submitted work is accepted elsewhere, withdraw immediately through the submission manager.

The reading fee debate produces genuine disagreement. The argument for: fees offset operational costs and slow the submission torrent to manageable levels. The argument against: fees create economic barriers that disadvantage writers without financial cushion, functionally making the field less accessible. Neither position is without merit, and the creative writing community has not reached consensus.

The cover letter presents a subtler tradeoff. Publication credits signal to editors that work has already been vetted — but over-provider minor credits can read as insecurity rather than confidence. First-time submitters without credits are not penalized by leaving that line blank; editors make decisions on the manuscript, not the biography.

Common misconceptions

Misconception: Personalized rejections are invitations to resubmit. A note saying "strong writing, not right for us" is an honest explanation, not a door left ajar. Unless the rejection explicitly says "please send us something else," it is a closed decision.

Misconception: Acceptance rates are uniformly low across all journals. The under-1% figure cited for flagship journals does not represent the field. Newer online journals and genre-specific publications regularly publish acceptance rates in the 3–8% range. Duotrope's aggregate data for tracked journals shows a mean acceptance rate closer to 1.5–2%, but variance is wide.

Misconception: Longer response times signal interest. A submission held for 5 months is more often the result of volume and staffing than editorial deliberation about a particular piece.

Misconception: Published work can be submitted again elsewhere. Once a journal publishes a piece under FNASR, that specific right has been used. Reprinting requires explicit reprint rights from a second journal and disclosure of the prior publication.

Checklist or steps (non-advisory framing)

A complete, well-prepared literary magazine submission includes the following elements:

Reference table or matrix

Journal Genre Simultaneous Submissions Reading Fee Approx. Response Time Pays
Ploughshares Fiction, Poetry, Nonfiction Yes No (standard); $3 Submittable fee 3–6 months Yes
Tin House Fiction, Poetry, Nonfiction Yes No 3–5 months Yes
One Story Fiction (one story per issue) Yes No 3–6 months Yes ($500)
The Sun Fiction, Poetry, Nonfiction No (exclusive) No 3–6 months Yes
Narrative Magazine Fiction, Poetry, Nonfiction No (exclusive) Yes ($20–24) 1–3 months Yes
SmokeLong Quarterly Flash Fiction (≤1,000 words) Yes No 30–60 days No
Strange Horizons Speculative Fiction, Poetry No No 60–90 days Yes (SFWA rates)
AGNI Fiction, Poetry, Nonfiction Yes No 3–5 months Yes

Response times and fees change; verify current policies directly on each journal's submissions page before submitting.

References

Read Next

Submitting Your Creative Writing: A Guide to the Process ANA › Life Services Authority › Creative Writing Authority › Submitting Your Creative Writing: A Guide to the Process... Poetry Writing: Forms, Techniques, and Traditions ANA › Life Services Authority › Creative Writing Authority › Poetry Writing: Forms, Techniques, and Traditions Poetry Writing:... Creative Nonfiction: Memoir, Essays, and Personal Narrative ANA › Life Services Authority › Creative Writing Authority › Creative Nonfiction: Memoir, Essays, and Personal Narrative...